佐々木三冬
Recently, I tried comparing dorayaki from some famous dorayaki shops like "Ueno Usagiya," "Suzumeya," and "Kusuduki," thinking I would be completely satisfied, but I realized that even the dorayaki from these "famous" places didn't quite match my taste... What exactly is my ideal dorayaki? After some thought, I came up with the following criteria:
1) A bit large for a satisfying bite
2) Plenty of sweet bean paste - this is important! (laughs)
3) The skin should not be too thick (balanced with the bean paste)
4) Sweet, but not overly sweet
But what is the basis for this "ideal dorayaki"? The dorayaki I used to eat a lot in the past was the "Mikasayama" from Bunmeido Tokyo. My dorayaki image is probably based on that... I wonder if I actually prefer Mikasayama over dorayaki from famous shops...? However, I haven't eaten it in years, so I don't remember the taste well. For this reason, I decided to buy dorayaki from Bunmeido for verification.
By the way, did you know that there are 7 companies with the name "Bunmeido"? I only found out when I researched it this time... To put it simply, the first one was founded in Nagasaki in 1900, then expanded to Tokyo. From there, it split into 7 companies.
I purchased the dorayaki from what I believe is the most common store in the Tokyo area, "Bunmeido Tokyo." Bunmeido has the same product name even in different companies, which makes it confusing... Anyway, after the long introduction, I finally tried the Mikasayama.
★ Mikasayama 162 yen
Shelf life is 8 days. Looking at the ingredients, the skin contains honey, corn syrup, sake, soy sauce, etc. The bean paste contains corn syrup and agar. It feels lighter than I imagined when I hold it. I thought it would be heavier. The amount of bean paste is relatively "normal." I thought there would be more. The skin is quite sweet, but the texture is light. The bean paste is slightly less moist and sweet. It might be due to the corn syrup and agar. The bean paste uses "Hokkaido Dainagon azuki." Both the skin and bean paste are sweet, so overall it's a bit on the sweet side. However, as expected from a long-established standard, the taste balance is well maintained. The bean paste is sweet but slightly less, balanced by the sweetness of the skin. However, it wasn't quite my "ideal" as I imagined. The bean paste was less than I thought, and it wasn't as heavy (laughs). So, where does my image of "ideal dorayaki" come from? Was it just a phantom created in my mind? (laughs) "Mikasayama" is deliciously made as a standard, so I would be happy to have it, but I probably wouldn't go out of my way to buy it...
★ Golden Mikasayama 216 yen
Shelf life is 4 days. The expiration date is half of Mikasayama. This dorayaki feels a bit heavier when held. As the name suggests, the skin is quite yellow. Maybe because of the high egg content. Also, using wasanbon sugar in the skin gives it a refined sweetness. The skin is fluffy and soft. It's quite similar to the skin from "Suzumeya." I really like this skin.